Tuesday, 8 March 2016

Bibek Debroy Speaks At UNESCO About The Wonder That Is Sanskrit


Even more so than before, Dr. Debroy needs no introduction, especially to readers of this blog. His column Dharma, Artha, Kama, Moksha was a runaway success, and can be easily accessed in the archives of this blog. Today, Bibek has been kind enough to share with us, a talk he gave at UNESCO on Sanskrit. Normally, he speaks extempore, but the gods have been kind in that he scripted this one. As it turned out, he didn't need to speak directly from it anyway! To the good fortune of all Sanskrit lovers, here is the full text of the talk.





The Wonder that is Sanskrit
            Bibek Debroy
            I stand before you as a representative of an old civilization, to speak about an old language.  This is a celebration of International Mother Language Day.  Acknowledging Bangladesh’s role in getting the UN system to give 21st February that recognition, let me refer to it as আন্তর্জাতিক মাতৃভাষা দিবস.  I wish to speak to you about संस्कृत (Sanskrit).  I cannot say that Sanskrit is my mother language, my mother tongue, my মাতৃভাষা.  It is much more than that.  Indians are multi-lingual.  Because of the fuzzy border been language and dialect, I can’t even tell you how many languages are spoken in India.  Around 125 are major languages, but another 1500 minor languages are spoken.  In a way, each of these is a mother language.  22 languages are listed in a Schedule to the Constitution.  This gives them an official kind of status.  Sanskrit is one of these and Sanskrit also has official language status in a State like Uttarakhand.

            Once every ten years, we have a Census.  The last Census was in 2011, but we still don’t have details from that Census on India’s great linguistic diversity.  For the preceding Censuses, the number of people who reported Sanskrit as a mother tongue was 2,212 in 1971, 6,106 in 1981, 49,736 in 1991 and 14,135 in 2001.  That is no indicator of how many people in India actually speak Sanskrit.  As I have said, India is multi-lingual.  Indians speak more than one language.  For Sanskrit to be the first language or mother tongue is rare.  But it can be the 3rd or 4th.  We don’t capture that. Hence, we don’t know how many Indians speak Sanskrit.  We capture this imperfectly and inadequately.  That’s also probably the reason why those Census numbers show that kind of fluctuation from one Census to another.

            In case, someone has told you Sanskrit is a dead language, please disabuse that person.  As I have said, there are 14,135 people who still declare it their mother tongue.  A slightly dated 2005 study listed more than 3000 books written in Sanskrit, published after India’s Independence in 1947.  We have something called the Sahitya Akademi.  It is like a National Academy for Letters.  Every year, it gives awards to literary works.  Since 1956, there has been an award for Sanskrit.  In the initial years of these Sahitya Akademi awards, works on Sanskrit, not necessarily in Sanskrit, were also given awards.  However, since 1967, those awards have been restricted to works written in Sanskrit.  True, there hasn’t been an award every year.  Bust since 167, 42 authors have been given such awards on works straddling research, poetry, epic poetry, biography, novels and short stories.  In a separate Sahitya Akademi category of literature written for children, compositions in Sanskrit have been conferred awards.   There are many Sanskrit academies which give awards to works in Sanskrit. There are 15 Sanskrit universities.  Schools teach Sanskrit.  There are thousands of Sanskrit colleges and traditional “toll”s which are affiliated to the Sanskrit Universities. Since 1970, the Rashtrya Sanskrit Sansthan, a deemed university, has existed to propagate and develop Sanskrit.  Films have been made in Sanskrit, not thousands of years ago, films didn’t exist then.  Adi Shankaracharya, conventionally dated to 788-820 CE, was a great philosopher and religious teacher.  In 1983, a film in Sanskrit was produced on his life.  Most of you have heard of the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna’s teachings to Arjuna on the eve of the battle of Kurukshetra and part of the great epic, Mahabharata.  A film in Sanskrit, titled “Bhagavad Gita” was produced in 1983.  A Sanskrit poet and playwright, Vishakhadatta wrote a play titled “Mudrarakshasa”.  This was about the great emperor Chandragupta Maurya, dated to the 4th and 3rd century BCE.  We don’t know precisely when the play was written, the range is between the 4th and 8th century CE.  The point is that in 2006, the play was rendered into a Sanskrit film.  In 2016, we will have an animated film in Sanskrit, crowd-funded and crowd-sourced, titled “Punyakoti”.  There are more than 75 dailies, weeklies and monthlies in Sanskrit.  There is television news in Sanskrit.  There are people who tweet in Sanskrit, including the Prime Minister.  On twitter, every day, there is something called Sanskrit Appreciation Hour, an attempt to teach Sanskrit.  In the state of Karnataka, there are two famous villages known as Mattur and Hosahalli.  In those villages, everyone speaks Sanskrit, even today.
            

Unlike an “extinct” language, there is no proper definition of a “dead” language.  Whatever be the definition, I don’t see any signs of it being “dead”.  There is a completely different point about knowledge of Sanskrit not perceived to possess commercial value.  But certainly at a forum like UNESCO’s, we shouldn’t talk about objects that only have commercial value, as determined in the market-place.

            With this preliminary, सर्वेभ्यो नमः which means नमस्ते.  I bow down before all of you.  Namaste.  You must have heard the expression “namaste” several times, without necessarily knowing what it means.  This is our way of saying “hello” in Sanskrit.  “Namaste” means “I bow down before you” and it conveys a sense of humility.  I am sure most of you know that “I”, with a capital, is alien to all our languages, Sanskrit included.
            Most Indian languages, in greater or lesser degree, trace their roots in Sanskrit.  In that sense, more than a mother tongue, Sanskrit is a grandmother tongue.  Indeed, that influence extends beyond the boundaries of today’s India, to elsewhere in Asia.  Nepal’s motto is जननी जन्मभूमिश्च स्वर्गादपी गरीयसी.  This is taken from the Valmiki Ramayana and means, “The mother and the mother-land are superior to heaven.”  In Angor Wat, the word Angor comes from the Sanskrit नगर, meaning “city”.  There are several such instances in South Asia and South East Asia.
The word संस्कृत means polished or refined.  It is allied to words like संस्कृति (samskriti), meaning culture or civilization, and संस्कार (samskara), meaning purificatory ceremony or sacrament.  However, don’t form the impression that the language has all along been called Sanskrit.  For hundreds, perhaps thousands, of years, the language was simply called भाषा (bhasha), language.  We don’t quite know when the language actually came to be called Sanskrit, but it was almost certainly not before the 6th century BCE.  If you know a little bit about Sanskrit, you may have been told Sanskrit was spoken by the upper classes, typically males, the brahmanas and the kshatriyas, the priests and the nobles.  Such propositions are advanced as definitive conclusions, beyond a shadow of doubt.
Let me relate three anecdotes about Swami Vivekananda (1863-1902).  Swami Vivekananda had a disciple named Sharatchandra Chakravarty and he kept a diary.  This was in Bengali, but has since been translated into English.  Shri Ramakrishna had a householder disciple named Nag Mahashaya (1846-99). On one occasion, in 1897, when Sharatchandra Chakravarty was present, another disciple, who frequently visited Nag Mahashaya, came to meet Swami Vivekananda and mentioned Nag Mahashaya.  Swami Vivekananda addressed this disciple in Sanskrit and said वयं तत्वान्वेषान् मधुकर हत्वास् त्वं खलु कृती। This was a reference to Nag Mahashaya’s great spiritual success.  Translated, “We have been destroyed in our pursuit of the truth.  O bee!  You are the one who has indeed been successful.”  One of the greatest of Sanskrit poets was Kalidasa.  We don’t know much about his biographical details, or about when he lived and wrote, probably between the 2nd century BC and the 5th century CE.  Among Kalidasa’s works are Malavikagnimitram (the love story between King Agnimitra and Malavika), Abhijnanashakuntalam (the famous Shakuntala story), Vikramorvashiyam (the story of King Pururava and Urvashi), Raghuvamsha (the story of King Prabhu’s dynasty), Kumarasambhava (the birth of Kumara or Skanda), Ritusamhara (about the seasons) and Meghadutam (when the cloud was used as a messenger).  What’s remarkable is not that Swami Vivekananda spoke in Sanskrit, but that he used a quote and a quote from literature.  Those Sanskrit words are part of a quote and they are a quote from Kalidasa’s Abhijnanashakuntalam.  The Shakuntala story is about King Dushyanta and Shakuntala and King Dushyanta said this when a bee was hovering around Shakuntala’s lips.  The second anecdote is about Swami Vivekananda’s trip to Ernakulam, in 1892.  Swami Vivekananda may have spoken in English in Chicago in 1893, and written and lectured extensively in Sanskrit, but when he travelled around the country, he conversed in Sanskrit.  In Ernakulam in 1892, when someone pointed out a grammatical error in Swami Vivekananda’s Sanskrit, he remarked, “I need not follow grammar; grammar will follow me.”  Third, there is a famous text of Vedanta, attributed to the sage Ashtavakra. As Narendranath Dutta, Swami Vivekananda used to visit Ramakrishna.  At that time, Swami Vivekananda was still searching. However, Ramakrishna recognized his potential.  To awaken seeds of Vedanta in Narendranath Dutta, Ramakrishna asked him to translate the Ashtavakra Gita for him, from Sanskrit to Bengali.  In this respect, there was nothing unusual about Swami Vivekananda.  In that day and age, many people spoke and read Sanskrit.  With many languages and dialects, it was a language used for communicating among different parts of the country.

There was a famous Sanskrit poet named Sriharsha, circa 12th century CE.  He wrote a great epic (Mahakavya) named Naishada Charita.  This was about the famous King Nala.  Nala married Damayanti, through what is called a svayamvara, a ceremony where a lady, typically a princess, chooses a husband from among assembled prospective suitors.  From different parts of the country, many kings assembled for Damayanti’s svayamvara.  Naishada Charita tells us अन्योन्यभाषानवबोधभीतेः संस्कृत्रिमार्भिव्यवहारवत्सु। दिग्भ्यः समेतेषु नृपेषु तेषु सौवर्गवर्गो न जनैरचिहिन॥  A free translation, not an exact translation, is something like this.  “There were kings who had assembled from different parts of the country.  They were scared that they would not understand each other’s mother tongues.  Therefore, they conversed with each other in Sanskrit.”  As a language to bridge different parts of the country, the 12th century wasn’t that different from the 19th.
But what of the proposition that Sanskrit was spoken by the upper classes, typically males, the brahmanas and the kshatriyas, the priests and the nobles, the elite?  This is offered as a theorem, when it is no more than a hypothesis.  We are talking about many thousands of years.  A hypothesis true at one point of time may well be false at another point of time.  Examples are cited from plays, where the so-called elite speak in Sanskrit and the so-called hoi polloi speak in prakrita, the vernacular or colloquial language.  Who were these plays for?  Did ordinary citizens witness their performance?  If they did, they must have understood Sanskrit.  Indeed, this negates the proposition that ordinary people did not understand Sanskrit.  I have already mentioned that संस्कृत means polished and it wasn’t used as an appellation for the language until much later.  It is perfectly possible for the elite to speak a refined form of the language, while ordinary people converse in a coarser variant.  I remember a book titled “The King’s English”, written by the Fowler brothers in 1906.  That determined correct English grammar and language.  A lot of people spoke and speak cockney and slang.  King’s English is refined and polished, so to speak, though few people spoke it, or speak it.  Am I therefore write in proposing that English is dead?  There were great Sanskrit grammarians like Panini (before the 5th century BCE) and Patanjali (also 2nd century BCE, though there may have been more than one Patanjali).  Too much grammar tends to kill the living character of a language.  One can cite from the works of Panini and Patanjali to establish that Sanskrit was a thriving spoken language, with regional variations, when these works were written. 

Patanjali’s text on grammar is known as Mahabhashya.  This is like a commentary on Panini’s grammar text, known as Ashtadhyayi.  There is a delightful between a grammarian (वैयाकरणः) and a charioteer (सूतः), an inferior varna, in 2.4.56 of Mahabhashya.  The grammarian asks the charioteer कः अस्य रथस्य प्रवेता इति। “Who is the charioteer of this chariot?”  The use of the word प्रवेता for driver or charioteer was wrong.  It should have been प्राजिता.  The charioteer corrects the grammarian, आयुष्मन् अहम् प्राजिता इति। “O one with a long life!  I am the driver.”  Perhaps understandably, the grammarian becomes angry and says ओहो खलु अनेन दुरुतेन बाध्यामहे इति। “Alas!  This duruta is annoying me.”  The word duruta means badly-woven and was wrongly used.  The grammarian meant duhsuta, or bad charioteer.  The charioteer corrects him again, दुःसूतेन इति वक्तव्यम्। “One should say duhsuta.”  This is reminiscent of another conversation between a bard and a king.  Playing on words, the bard tells the king अहं च त्वं च राजेन्द्र लोकनाथौ उभावपि। बहुव्रीहिरहं राजन् षष्ठीतत्पुरूषो भवान् ।।  Sanskrit is a language that flows freely, like water.  It does not like stops.  It is essentially a spoken language and was rendered into writing much later.  Even when it was rendered into writing, many different scripts were used.  The use of Devanagari as a script is of very recent vintage.  Most of the principles of Sanskrit grammar are based on this principle of letters and words freely merging into one another to form compound letters and compound words.  Two of these principles are called sandhi and samasa.  The bard used two different kinds of samasa, bahuvirhi and shashthi-tatpurusha, to change the meaning entirely.  The literal translation is “O king!  Both you and I are Lokanathas.  I am bahuvrihi and you are shashti-tatpurusha.”  This translation doesn’t make any sense to someone who doesn’t know samasa.  Hence, “O king!  Both you and I are Lokanathas.  I am one whose master (नाथ) is the world (लोक) and you are one who is master (नाथ) of the world (लोक).”

So much for Sanskrit being restricted to kshatriyas and brahmanas.  The Vedas are ancient Sanskrit texts.  The word वेद (Veda) means knowledge.  The word Vedas is used both in a narrow and in a broad sense.  In a narrow sense, Vedas is used for what is called the samhitas.  These are mantras.  There are four Vedas – Rig, Yajur, Sama and Atharva, associated with four kinds of priests who performed the rituals.  It is impossible to date the Vedas precisely.  The earliest, the Rig Veda, probably goes back to at least 2000 BCE.  एकं सत् विप्राः बहुधा वदन्ति। “Truth is one.  Learned men speak of it in various ways.”  This is an expression you may have heard of.  It comes from the Rig Veda, from I.CLXIV.46 to be precise.  In a broad sense, the Vedas also include the Brahmanas, commentaries on the mantras.  They also include the Aranyakas (rituals and philosophical speculations) and the Upanishads (metaphysical speculations and philosophy).  However, the dividing line between the Aranyakas and the Upanishads is thin.  The Upanishads are a treasure-house of wisdom.  The word Vedanta literally means the end of the Vedas and is a term used for the Upanishads, as well as some subsequent texts.  If you have been to India, or are familiar with India, you may have noticed the national motto, also embossed on currency notes.  If I write a letter to you, this expression will be on my letter-head.  This states सत्यमेव जयते, satyameva jayate, truth alone triumphs.  This quote comes from the Mundaka Upanishad.  Perhaps I should quote the shloka in its entirety.  सत्यमेव जयते नानृतं सत्येन पन्था विततो देवयानः। येनाक्रमन्त्यृषयो ह्याप्तकामा यत्र तत् सत्यस्य परमं निधानम्॥  “Truth alone triumphs, not falsehood.  It is through truth that the path of the gods is laid out.  It is by following this that the sages obtained their wishes and reached the supreme foundation of truth.”  How many Upanishads are there?  This isn’t a question that can be easily answered.  There are major Upanishads and there are minor ones.  Depending on which ones you include, there major Upanishads number 11 to 13.  There are 100-200 minor Upanishads.

This entire corpus, Vedas, Brahmanas, Aranyakas and Upanishads are part of what is called the shruti tradition.  They are revelation, they weren’t composed by any human agent, as per the Indian tradition.  There were rishis or sages who composed the mantras. However, strictly speaking, they weren’t composers or authors.  These were revealed to them.  The shruti tradition is distinct from the smriti tradition.  Smriti texts had human authors.  The Bhagavad Gita forms part of the great epic, the Mahabharata, and represents Krishna’s teachings to Arjuna on the eve of the Kurukshetra War.  It derives its essence from the Upanishads.  Despite this, the Mahabharata and the Bhagavad Gita were actually composed by the sage Krishna Dvaipayana Vedavyasa.  As such, the Bhagavad Gita is a smriti text, not a shruti text.  I mentioned rishis.  In the Rig Veda, one can count a total of 407 rishis.  21 of these were women.  If one propounds the hypothesis regardless of timelines, it is hence impossible to prove that Sanskrit was spoken exclusively by males.
Since 2003, India has a National Mission for Manuscripts (Namami). This has a gargantuan task of listing, digitizing, publishing and translating manuscripts — a manuscript defined as a text more than 75 years old. This manuscript wealth isn’t necessarily in public hands. Hence, surveys are used to estimate what’s in private collections. As of now, Namami has a listing/ digitization of three million and the estimated stock of manuscripts in India is 35 million. There are at least 60,000 manuscripts in Europe and another 1,50,000 elsewhere in South Asia. Ninety-five per cent of these manuscripts have never been listed, collated and translated. To give some idea of how large 35 million is, since the advent of printing, an estimated 130 million books have been published in all languages of the world.  Most people here will have heard of Kautilya (350—275 BCE) and the text on political economy and governance that he authored, titled Arthashastra.  I don’t know how many of you know that the manuscript of Arthashastra had been lost.  It was rediscovered by R. Shamasastry in 1904, published in 1909 and translated into English in 1915.  Who knows how many such treasures lie hidden in the form of manuscripts?  Let me reiterate what I said earlier.  Writing is new in Sanskrit is new and writing in the Devanagari script came even later.  Even when the language was Sanskrit, the script may have been something that few people know how to read today.  The sharada script, widely used in Kashmir once, is an example.  I have asked several learned people – how many people can read sharada today?  The invariable answer is, one or two, but no one seems to know who these one or two individuals are.  There was also something called Brihatkatha, a collection of stories written by Gunadhya in 6th century CE.  This was in a language called paishachi and both Brihatkatha and the paishachi language have vanished.  To compound the problem, knowledge was transmitted verbally, not in written form, through a guru-shishya or preceptor-disciple mode.  We have no idea of how much knowledge has been lost in the process.  Take the Rig Veda as an example.  Originally, this was believed to have 21 shakhas, schools or recensions.  The Yajur Veda had 101 shakhas.  The Sama Veda had 1000 shakhas.  The Atharva Veda had 9 shakhas.  Together, the four Vedas had 1131 shakas. Now, there are onhly 13 left. What has been irretrievably lost is beyond redemption.  Let us at least save what remains.

I have erred in two ways.  First, I have conveyed the impression that all the manuscripts are in Sanskrit.  They aren’t.  Roughly two-thirds are in Sanskrit.  However, there are other languages too, Arabic and Pali are examples.  I have also conveyed the impression that all Sanskrit texts are connected to Hinduism.  They aren’t.  Many Buddhist and Jain texts were written in Sanskrit.  There is a text known as Amara-Kosha, also known as Namalinganushasana.  This was authored by a Sanskrit grammarian and poet, named Amara Sinha (4th century CE).  This text is a bit like a dictionary or thesaurus and is probably one of the earliest in the world.  Surprise of surprises, it is used by students of Sanskrit even today, as something to refer to.  I have it on my I-pad.  Though we don’t know much about Amara Sinha’s personal life, he clearly seems to have been a Buddhist.  There is a book titled “A Companion to Sanskrit Literature”, authored by Sures Chandra Banerji.  This was originally published in 1971 and has gone through several editions since.  This volume traverses 3000 years of Sanskrit literature and has an entire chapter on the contribution of Muslims to Sanskrit.  By the way, this isn’t the only such documentation.  Since 1971, other books have also documented this contribution.

I used the word philosophy earlier.  The Sanskrit word darshana is better, since it carries a nuance of insight.  Traditionally, there were six schools of darshana – samkhya, yoga, nyaya, vaisheshika, purva mimasa and uttara mimasa (Vedanta). Add to that the agama and tantra literature, both less orthodox and unconventional.  To the extent they survive, they are generally in Sanskrit.  While these are triggered by what can broadly be called the metaphysical and spiritual, they also get into areas that are less obviously religious.  This is true in greater measure when we get into the Vedangas, meaning, limbs of the Vedas.  Traditionally, there are six of these – shiksha (phonetics), kalpa (rituals), vyakarana (grammar), nirukta (etymology), Chhanda (metre) and jyotisha (astronomy).  The rules formalized by Panini in his work on grammar have influenced the development of formal language theory.  The kalpa branch led to the development of the shulba sutras.  Along this line, the work of Apastamba (450-350 BCE) and Baudhayana (8th to 7th century BCE) led to mathematical advances like the Pythagorean theorem, Pythagorean triples and the square root of 2, the last leading to the notion of irrational numbers.  One should not misunderstand.  One should not look for axiomatic step by step deductive proofs.  Instead, in 1.11 of Baudhayana’s shulba sutra, one will have a statement like the following. दीर्घचतुरश्रस्याक्ष्णयारज्जु: पार्श्र्वमानी तिर्यग्मानी च यत् पृथग्भूते कुरूतस्तदुभयं करोति॥ Translated, “When a rope is stretched along the length of the diagonal, it produces an area which is what the vertical and the horizontal sides make together.”  Geometry was important because the shulba sutras were about constructions of sacrificial altars.  Jyotisha led to the work of Aryabhatta (476-550 CE), Varahamihira (505-587 CE), Brahmagupta (598-665 CE) and Bhaskara (600-680 CE).  These works were in Sanskrit and the contributions in geometry, trigonometry, algebra and combinatorics have been sufficiently well documented.  Combinatorics reminds me of chhanda shastra and the work of Pingala (probably 1st century CE).  The structure of Sanskrit prosody was different.  Rhyming was unimportant.  Instead, there was a very tight structure of metres, into what can be light and heavy syllables.  There were fewer metres in Vedic Sanskrit.  But as Vedic Sanskrit morphed into classical Sanskrit, there were at least 1000 different metres.  Pingala’s work took him to a binary number system, combinatorics, the binomial theorem and Fibonacci numbers.

Lest I forget, I should mention Ayurveda, treatises on medicine.  Literally, Ayurveda is better translated as knowledge of life.  There was the work of Charaka (2nd century CE), which was more about medicine and anatomy, and there was the work of Sushruta (1st century CE), which was about medicine and surgery.  Note that the original texts of the Sushruta Samhita and the Charaka Samhita no longer survive.  Note that works on dhanurveda (science of war and fighting) rarely survive too.  The Dharmashastras still determine much of ethics and good behavior.

The mention of prosody takes me to the realm of Sanskrit literature and there is a huge corpus there.  The Sanskrit word for poet is kavi, which actually means a wise person.  The earliest poet was Valmiki, composer of the Valmiki Ramayana.  Valmiki was the first poet, adi kavi.  I used the word shloka earlier.  Shloka means a couplet.  Have you wondered about the origin of the word shloka?  The story goes that the sage Valmiki went to the banks of the river Tamasa to have a bath.  A couple of curlews (krouncha) were making love.  Along came a hunter and shot down the male curlew.  The female curlew lamented at this.  Valmiki was stirred by compassion and wanted to curse the hunter.  However, this curse got transformed into the first couplet ever, in a metre known as anushtubh, a favoured metre in both the Valmiki Ramayana and the Mahabharata.  मा निषाद प्रतिष्ठां त्वमगमः शाश्वतीः समाः। यत्क्रौंचमिथुनादेकमवधीः काममोहितम्॥  “O hunter!  Since you have slain one of two curlews when they were engaged in an act of love, you will obtain ill-fame for an eternity.”  The word shoka means sorrow.  Since the couplet was composed against the background of sorrowing, this couplet came to be known as shloka.  So the Valmiki Ramayana tells us.  Just as Valimiki composed the Ramayana, the sage Krishna Dvaipayana Vyasa composed the Mahabharata.  There were two great dynasties in India, the solar dynasty and the lunar dynasty.  The Ramayana is the story of the solar dynasty, while the Mahabharata is the story of the lunar dynasty.  The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are not regarded as fiction.  They are called itihasa, meaning, this is indeed what happened.  They are believed to represent history.  To give you some idea of the size, the Valmiki Ramayana has 25,000 shlokas, while the Mahabharata has 100,000.  After composing the Mahabharata, Vyasa composed the eighteen major Puranas.  The Puranas are ancient accounts.  There are major Puranas and minor Puranas.  The eighteen major Puranas collectively amount to 400,000 shlokas.

Sanskrit literature started to flourish during what is called the classical period, say 3rd century CE onwards.  We had great playwrights like Shudraka, Bhasa, Ashvaghosa and Kalidasa.  There was a famous text known as natya shastra (2nd century CE), a treatise on stagecraft.  There were collections of popular tales, like Panchatantra and Hitopadesha.  There was poetry by Kalidasa, Bharavi, Maghaa and Sriharsha.  There were authors like Banabhatta, Vatsyayana and Bhartihari.  The list goes on and on.  Volumes have been written on this amazing corpus.  How can I hope to give you a flavor in the course of a brief talk?  You should read it for yourself.  But let me give you a few more examples.

शुष्कं काष्ठं तिष्ठति अग्रे। “A dry piece of wood is in front.”  I have just mentioned the great poet Banabhatta.  One of his sons, Bhushanabhatta, was also a great poet. There is a story that Banabhatta wished to decide which of his sons was better, as a poet. The sentence above is what the first son produced.  When it came to Bhushanabhatta’s turn, he produced नीरसः तरूवरः पुरतः भाति.  The words have exactly the same meaning.   Unlike शुष्कं, which only means “dry”, नीरसः means “without juice”.  काष्ठं means “wood”, while तरूवरः means “great tree”.  More than the meaning, the sound has got completely transformed. शुष्कं काष्ठं तिष्ठति अग्रे। नीरसतरूवरः पुरतः भाति. One is poetry, the other is not.

There is a story that once, King Bhoja and Kalidasa had a disagreement and Kalidasa left Dhara and went to live somewhere else.  While he was there, a message was brought to him that King Bhoja had died.  Kalidasa was distraught and composed the following shloka.  Though they had quarreled, Kalidasa still retained a lot of affection for King Bhoja. अद्य धारा निराधारा निरालम्बा सरस्वती। पण्डिताः खण्डिताः सर्वे भोजराजे दिवं गते॥ “Today, Dhara is without a foundation.  The goddess Sarasvati is without support.  All the learned men are disappointed or abandoned.  King Bhoja has gone to heaven.” A beautiful shloka, but there was a problem.  King Bhoja hadn’t actually died, that was wrong information.  When Kalidasa realized that he had been misled, he rejoiced.  As for the shloka, did it have to be abandoned?  Not quite.  Kalidasa changed it to the following.  अद्य धारा सदाधारा सदालम्बा सरस्वती। पण्डिताः मण्डिताः सर्वे भोजराजे भुवं गते॥ A little bit of tweaking and the entire meaning changes.  “With King Bhoja having gone to earth, Dhara always has a support and the goddess Sarasvati always has a support.  All the learned men are adorned.” You will say that it needed a Kalidasa to do this.  That’s undoubtedly true.  But you also needed the Sanskrit language to do this.  There are very few languages in the world where you could have done this.  That’s the beauty of Sanskrit.

Since Kalidasa is one of my favourite Sanskrit poets, I can go on and on about him. I have already mentioned मेघदूतम्.  This means “cloud-messenger”. It is impossible to capture the beauty in any English translation.   There is nothing in the story.  In fact, it is amazing that a poet should have composed a poem with no story-line, so to speak.  Kubera is the lord of riches and the lord of the yakshas and he lives in Alakapuri, on Mount Kailasha.  One of these yakshas has been negligent in his duties and Kubera banishes him from Alakapuri for one year.  He is banished to some place in the central parts of India.  There, he pines for his beloved wife, who is in Alakapuri.  It is the monsoon season and the yaksha decides to send a message to his beloved.  He uses the cloud as a messenger.  The Purvamegha part of the poem is about the cloud’s journey to Alakapuri and has 66 shlokas.  The Uttaramegha part of the poem is about the cloud’s return from Alakapuri and has 55 shlokas.  The beauty of the poem is in the description of nature.  What is the Sanskrit for a mushroom?  There are several and one is शिलिन्ध्र​.  Have you heard of any poet in the world bringing something like a mushroom into poetry?  I haven’t.  Here is the first part of shloka 11.  कर्तुं यच्च प्रभवति महीमुच्छिलीन्ध्रामवन्ध्यां.   “You are capable of making that ground fertile and make mushrooms sprout from it.” Let us move on to shloka 18. छन्नोपान्तः परिणतफलद्य्योतिभिः काननाम्रैस्त्वय्यारूढे शिखरमचल: स्निग्धवेणीसवर्णे। नूनं यास्यत्यमरमिथूनप्रेक्षणीयामवस्थां मध्ये श्यामः स्तन इव भुवः शेषविस्तारपाण्डुः ॥ “You have climbed up the peak of the mountain and the extremities are full of ripe mangos in the orchards and their complexion is affecting the hue.  As you have climbed up the mountain, because of your complexion, it looks as if a lady’s braided hair is lying atop the slope.  From above, a couple of immortals will certainly think that this is a sight worth looking at.  It is like a breast of the earth, dark in the centre and pale at the ends.”  What is left implicit is that this is the image of a pregnant lady’s breast.  This is the monsoon and soon, the earth will also begin to yield crops.  Meghadutam is nothing but stuff like this.  How can this be translated?  Don’t even bother to read a translation.  Read the Sanskrit.  Meghadutam represents the young Kalidasa at work, with poetry churned out of nowhere, that is, out of a cloud.  His more mature works came later.

I am going to move on to Magha.   He was from 7th century ACE, in what was then Gujarat, and is now Rajasthan.  Magha (Maagha) may have written several works, but the only one that has survived is Shishupala Vadha. Most people know the story of Krishna beheading Shishupala and this mahakavya (great epic) is about that incident.  About Magha it has been said, उपमा कालिदासस्य भारवेरर्थगौरवं| दण्डिन: पदलालित्यं माघे सन्ति त्रयो गुणाः|| We have four Sanskrit poets mentioned in that couplet – Kalidasa, Bharavi, Dandin and Magha.  “Kalidasa’s similes (metaphors), the deep purport of Bharavi’s words, the beauty of Dandin’s words – all three qualities are to be found in Magha.” Shishupala Vadha has 20 sargas.  Indeed, it is a mahakavya and many connoisseurs of Sanskrit poetry have raved about Magha.  The ingenuity reaches a crescendo in the 19th sarga.  Sanskrit poetry had a concept of चित्रकाव्य.  चित्र has many meanings – picture, wonderful, excellent.  So these are wonderful decorative compositions.  For example, how about composing a shloka with the first pada (quatrain) entirely in ज, the second pada entirely in त, the third pada entirely in भ and the fourth pada entirely in र?  Magha came up with जजौजोजाजिजिज्जाजी तं ततोऽतितताततुत्। भाभोऽभीभाभिभूभाभू- रारारिररिरीररः॥  Believe it or not, this means “Then the warrior, winner of war, with his heroic valour, the subduer of the extremely arrogant beings, he who has the brilliance of stars, he who has the brilliance of the vanquisher of fearless elephants, the enemy seated on a chariot, began to fight.”   Here is another example, composed only with भ and र. भूरिभिर्भारिभिर्भीराभूभारैरभिरेभिरे। भेरीरेभिभिरभ्राभैरभीरुभिरिभैरिभाः॥ This means, “The fearless elephant, who was like a burden to the earth because of its weight, whose sound was like a kettle-drum, and who was like a dark cloud, attacked the enemy elephant.”  As a third example, composed only with द, दाददो दुद्ददुद्दादी दाददो दूददीददोः। दुद्दादं दददे दुद्दे दादाददददोऽददः॥ The meaning is, “Sri Krishna, the giver of every boon, the scourge of the evil-minded, the purifier, the one whose arms can annihilate the wicked who cause suffering to others, shot his pain-causing arrow at the enemy.”  Magha also specialized in palindromes.  Here is one. वारणागगभीरा सा साराभीगगणारवा। कारितारिवधा सेना नासेधा वारितारिका॥ The translation is, “It is very difficult to face this army which is endowed with elephants as big as mountains. This is a very great army and the shouting of frightened people is heard. It has slain its enemies.”  Notice that each line is a palindrome, read right to left.  Magha was partly trying to rival Bharavi.  Bharavi wrote a mahakavya titled Kiratarjuniya and that was replete with palindromes too.  This work was about the duel between Arjuna and Shiva, the latter in the garb of a hunter. Ignoring the Bharavi palindromes, here is another remarkable example from Bharavi. विकाशमीयुर्जगतीशमार्गणा विकाशमीयुर्जगतीशमार्गणाः। विकाशमीयुर्जगतीशमार्गणा विकाशमीयुर्जगतीशमार्गणाः॥ The words only seem to repeat themselves.  However, the meaning is quite different. “The arrows (mārgaṇāḥ), of the king (jagatīśa) Arjuna spread out (vikāśam īyuḥ). The arrows (mārgaṇāḥ), of the lord of the earth (jagatīśa), Lord Śiva, spread out (vikāśam īyuḥ). The Gaṇas (gaṇāḥ) who are the slayers of demons (jagatīśamār) rejoiced (vikāśam īyuḥ). The seekers (mārgaṇāḥ) of Lord Śiva (jagatīśa), i.e. the deities and sages, reached (īyuḥ) the sky (vikāśam) (to watch the battle).”

One last example and I am done. Bhaskaracharya was a famous Indian mathematician and astronomer (1114-1185 CE).  He is also known as Bhaskara-II.  Leelavati is both the name of a text (actually part of a text) that he wrote and Leelavati is also believed to have been the name of his daughter.  Many of the problems are addressed to Leelavati and Leelavati also seems to have composed some of them. इन्द्र: वायुर्यमश्चैव नैरृतो मध्यमस्तथा । ईशानश्च कुबेरश्च अग्निर्वरुण एव च ॥ The one given above is one such, composed by Leelavati.  Why was this important enough to be written down in the form of a shloka?  It is just the names of various gods.  Actually, not just any gods.  This gives the names of lokapalas.  Lokapalas are protectors or guardians of the world.  There are 10 directions.  If you leave out above and below, there are 8.  These are north, north-east, east, south-east, south, south-west, west and north-west.  North, south, east and west have specific Sanskrit names as directions.  Vayu is the guardian of the north-west, Kubera of the north, Ishana of the north-east, Indra of the east, Agni of the south-east, Yama of the south, Nairrita of the south-west and Varuna of the west. 

Vayu
Kubera
Ishana
Varuna
Indra
Nairrtta
Yama
Agni

But what’s the point of the shloka?  Why write out a shloka that only lists the names of the lokapalas?  We know their names.  Follow the order listed by Leelavati, Indra is the first, Vayu is the second, Yama is the third and so on.  Madhyama means middle, there is no guardian there.  Fill in the matrix below in the order in which Leelavati has listed the names.
2
7
6
9
5
1
4
3
8

It is a 3X3 magic square, with the sums along all rows, all columns and all diagonals adding up to 15.  So that’s what she was doing.  She wasn’t writing down any odd shloka, she was actually constructing a magic square.  Interesting?  Sanskrit is littered with such nuggets.  If we don’t learn and read Sanskrit, all this will be lost.
            Sanskrit is a great wonder and it is a great heritage.  India’s Human Resource Development Ministry set up a Committee to recommend a long-term vision and road-map for the development of Sanskrit.  The Report was submitted recently and is available at http://mhrd.gov.in/report-committee-regarding-long-term-vision-and-road-map-development-sanskrit.  It will be a great pity if Sanskrit ever becomes a “dead” language.


Monday, 24 August 2015

David Stollar, former head of the Sanskrit Faculty at St. James comments on the dharma tradition

Please meet David Stollar, who is a founding member (if not the founder!) of the Sanskrit Facutly at St. James School in London. David is also my first Sanskrit tutor, because of whom I was able not only to teach my own son, but also take the IGCSE Sanskrit exam along with him, years ago. David is steeped in the Sanskrit tradition and continues to teach online after retiring from his calling as head of the Sanskrit faculty at St. James. If you want to get in touch with him, just leave a comment on this blogpost. He responds here to my  dharma tradition article, which you can read : http://www.dailyo.in/lifestyle/hinduism-manu-dharma-literature-sanskrit-ramayana-brahmin-vedic-india/story/1/5802.html
 


Dear Rohini,

I much enjoyed your article on the Dharmasastras. This seemed to me to be an eminently reasonable approach to the subject, and one which is sorely needed, else there is the danger of the whole wise tradition being rejected as unreasonable, insupportable and inhumane.

The approach you delineate rules out the scourges of fundamentalism on the one hand and unlicenced freethinking on the other. I particularly appreciated the fact that the clues to the subject and how it should be approached are contained in the very scriptures themselves.

I spent many years chairing a group translating the Manusmrti into English and it was intriguing how often the text, as you intimate, suggested more than one solution to a problem, and often these seemed, at first glance at least, to be wildly contradictory.

There is I believe a tradition that the text we call Manu’s originated from an effort, at a time when the ancient traditions were being forgotten, to collect the ancient verses still extant and to collate these in a more or less logical form. Thus in some cases contradictory verses are included together and also, as you point out, general rules indicated by the tradition for dealing with practical problems of interpretation.

Perhaps the most important point which underlies your exposition is that for modern India this is far from a merely historical or academic field of investigation. India is one of the few places surviving on our planet where there is still great respect for the thought of the ancients together with an innate recognition of a reality beyond the merely physical realm. Hence there is a real possibility of adapting the ancient but timeless traditions to the needs and valid aspirations of the world as we find it.

As for my initial warning of the twin but opposite dangers of fundamentalism and mere licence, the former is demonstrated by most forms of modern Islam; while the latter we see in the current ‘liberalisation’ of the once great Western religions. In this case the baby, as they say, is tending to be thrown out with bathwater. This makes me very sad.

As far as I can see, for both these extremes, the problem arises from a lack of real connection with the living Source. Only such a connection has the potential to generate genuine new forms and expressions. It seems to me, however, that this can only be made practical through the medium of a genuine tradition able to be drawn upon and illuminated anew.

The challenge therefore is to identify the modern ‘wise’ men (or women, manīṣibhiḥ as you quote) who can speak from (as far as possible) something approaching an unpolluted consciousness of reality. This is a tall order I know, but history shows that good people working together in a valid tradition to purify their being and strengthen their understanding have been known in the past to achieve something near to this.

Just a few thoughts and thank you again for your article.

Friday, 24 July 2015

Revise the past perfect with रामायण​ सुन्दरकाण्ड​ 10.54

Beginners, especially Hindi speakers, request you to pronounce the 'a' at the end of every 'a' ending word: cucumb-a, jagām-a, nanand-a, cikrīḍ-a etc.

Hanumān’s delight upon thinking that he has found the kidnapped Sitā:-



आस्फोटयाम् आस  चुचुम्ब पुच्छं ननन्द चिक्रीड जगौ  जगाम 
स्तम्भान् अरोहन् निपपात भूमौ  निदर्शयन् स्वां प्रकृतिं कपीनाम्

He struck [at his arms/chest with his hands], kissed his tail, rejoiced, sang, darted towards the pillars, shot up and jumped down to the ground, exhibiting/indicating his monkey-nature.






आस्फोटयामास - slapped, clapped; - 3rd person, sing, perfect  आ √स्फुट्
चुचुम्ब -kissed;  3rd person, sing, perfect √चुम्ब्  
ननन्द - rejoiced; 3rd person, sing, perfect √नन्द्
चिक्रीड -  frolicked, played; 3rd person, sing, perfect √क्रीड् 
जगौ  - sang; 3rd person, sing, perfect  √गै
जगाम -  went, darted; 3rd person, sing, perfect √गम्
स्तम्भान् pillars; masc, acc, pl.
अरोहत् climbed; 3rd person, sing, imperfect √रुह्
निपपात - jumped down; 3rd person, sing, perfect नि √पत्
भूमौ - to the ground; locative, fem, sing
निदर्शयन् -  indicating; causative, present participle नि दृश्
स्वाम् - his own pronoun, sing, agreeing with fem - prakṛti
कपीनाम् - belonging to, of monkeys, masc, genitive, plural
प्रकृतिम् - acc, fem, sing - nature.

Sunday, 19 July 2015

asataḥ mā sadgamaya (Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 1.3.28)

In response to a query on Twitter:



asataḥ mā sadgamaya
tamasaḥ mā jyotirgamaya
mṛtyoḥ mā amṛtamgamaya
(Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 1.3.28)

In sadgamaya, jyotirgamaya, amṛtamgamaya as @haritirumalai pointed out, sad, jyotir and amṛtam are all in the accusative case (2nd), and appear in the stem form; and as per sandhi rules in compound with gamaya - which I mentioned earlier was a causative imperative, 'cause me to go, lead me.' As you rightly pointed out, gam takes the accusative, so that's taken care of. Because of the stem form, the case ending that was confusing you, is dropped. (santam santau sataḥ) And all three are neuters. Tamas and jyotis are anyway, and amṛta can be m/n/f, but in the sense of immortality it is a neuter.

Now the first part of each sentence could have be interpreted two ways depending on whether you take mā to be not/don't, or whether you take it to be the enclitic for mām - meaning mujh ko, mujhe, 'me' as I first reacted. But, since asataḥ , tamasaḥ and mṛtyoḥ are all in the ablative case (5th), there is no scope for ambiguity, and @haritirumalai got it right the first time.

Tuesday, 30 June 2015

My response to Shoaib Daniyal's article "Fact check: India wasn't the first place Sanskrit was recorded – it was Syria"

It is not my intention here to comment on what the Modi government is doing with Sanskrit. Neither do I intend to delve into the 'origin' theories surrounding Sanskrit. Nor the Central Asian Urheimat hypothesis. This response is motivated primarily by Shoaib's suggestive lead in -  "Fact Check." My simple intention is to question some of the presuppositions and 'facts' in Shoaib's article. To point out that in some places the title and subheadings of the article are at variance with his own copy. And that in my humble opinion, he has got this quite wrong. 

In http://scroll.in/article/737715/fact-check-india-wasnt-the-first-place-sanskrit-was-recorded-it-was-syria Drawing on the scholarship of  David Anthony, Thomas Burrows and others, Shoaib suggests that Sanskrit was first recorded in (modern day) Syria. The basis of this claim is a treaty signed in the 14th century BCE between the Hatti and the Mittani. Other proof includes Kikkuli's  horse training manual in Hittite which has words which are similar or the same as those found in Sanskrit. He may well have added the names of Mitanni princes on cuneiform documents in Akkadian from the Bogazk6y and El-Amarna tablets.

I'm a bit surprised by the following:

1.)His own article specifies that the Mitanni were speakers of a language called Hurrian. (Not Sanskrit)

2.) The treaty itself was not scripted in Sanskrit and only bears the names (or equivalents) of 3+2 deities who are well established in the Rig Veda. The lists of the Aryan gods on the Hatti-
Mitanni and the Mitanni-Hatti treaties reads as in the picture below. You can see it is not Sanskrit, but the names are recognisable as Indra, Mitra, Varuna and the Nasatyas (From Thieme, Journal of the American Oriental Society, Vol. 80, No. 4):


3.) These deities were 'wedged between' all of the deities of the Hatti and the Mitanni.  Clearly indicating that they had their own pantheons in addition to these 5 gods. From Thieme (ibid.)

















4) Shoaib says clearly that the region in question is "what is now northern Syria" - yet he has no problem in sub-heading the section "The Syrian speakers of Sanskrit" when in fact Syria/Syrians were nowhere in sight and would not come into existence for at least 3 millenia after this treaty. Quite misleading.

5) Indologists like Theodore Proferes quote the Mitanni treaty merely as a chronological marker - saying that if the Indo-Aryan gods (as opposed to Proto-Aryan;See Thieme ibid.) feature in the Mitanni treaty, and if they were worshiped for the same functions in the Rig Veda - the hymns are at least as old as the treaty. However Proferes is the first to admit that Max Mueller's dating is arbitrary and there is nothing which says the Rig Veda was not composed centuries before this date.

6) The truth is no one actually know how old the Rig Veda is, and therefore how old Vedic Sanskrit is. Or when it branched off from the Proto-Aryan language pool (assuming there was on), as did Avestan. If we are checking 'facts', the Aitareya Brāhmaṇa  suggests an alternate date. It contains a passage which refers to the shifting of the vernal equinox from the Naksatra Mrgasiras to Rohini. According to some astronomers, this event is likely to have occurred around 3500 B.C. If this is a 'fact', the Rigveda, being older than the Aitareya Brāhmaṇa would be assignable to the 4th millennium BCE (See B.B. Lal, East and West, Vol. 48, No. 3/4) 1,900 years before the Mitanni treaty.

7) Shoaib unqualified-ly quotes PIE (Proto Indo-European) as the founding language of Sanskrit. He doesn't consider it necessary to explain PIE itself is a scholarly construct and there is by no means any agreement on whether it actually existed. Linguistic scholars like N.S. Trubetskoy categorically deny its existence. Even a scholar like Ernst Pulgram who does believe that PIE existed admits, "...a procedure whereby we choose to arrive at a reconstructed proto-language, be it Proto-Indo-European or Proto-Athapaskan, by comparing languages in pairs and advancing by way of a pyramid until we have reached the summit, the reconstructed proto-language, does not in the least entitle us to believe, or postulate, that historically the reverse process-that is, a series of binary splits-actually occurred." So when the jury is still out on PIE I would be very uncomfortable with adding gravitas to an article by quoting PIE (founding language) as a 'Fact.'

I have great respect for Shoaib Daniyal but I don't agree with his reading of where and when Sanskrit was first spoken. Had he presented this article as an optional reading, I might have enjoyed it. But not as a "Fact Check." I do not claim to know the answers myself. However what little I have garnered suggests that Sanskrit was certainly not spoken for the first time in the 14th century BCE in a region that 3,000+ years later would become Syria. In fact far from what the subtitle of his article suggests, Sanskrit wasn't spoken there at all. All that has been proved is that there were linguistic similarities between Hittite, Hurrian and Sanskrit, and that a handful of the deities were shared in common with the people of the Rig Veda. I look forward to a response from Shoaib on this article.


















Sunday, 22 February 2015

Kaushalyaa : A story of a perfect mother, a perfect wife- yet neglected by her husband


Please welcome back guest writer* Gyanendra Narayan, who enchanted us last year with his perspective on ideas of physical beauty as it appears in the ancient texts.** Today Gyan brings to our notice a mother who perhaps hasn't got her due as compared, say to Yashoda or Kunti. We all know who she is, but how much do we really know about her? Read on, comment, share your views. You can follow Gyan and interact with him on Twitter  










Kaushalyaa :  A story of a perfect mother, a perfect wife- yet neglected by her husband

Raamaayana, when compared against Mahaabhaarata, comes out to be an epic where things are ideal and perfect. Maryaadaa Purushottam Raama gives us a world which is ideal and perfect. Mahaabhaarata walks away with prize of having all the emotions of human world, but Raamaayan also has grey shaded of human life. In this series, I have picked up a thread of conversation by Queen Kaushalya-  a perfect mother, a perfect wife but neglected half of King Dasharatha.

Read more to find out how neglected Kaushalyaa seeks the anchor of her life in Lord Raama.

Context:
Kaikeyi has asked for her 2 boons which were due with King Dasharatha. First being exile of Lord Raama in forest for 14 years and another being coronation of Bharata. Raama has been informed of this decision and now he has come to meet his mother Kaushalyaa. Queen Kaushalya ,always neglected because of beautiful Kaikeyi and affinity of Dasharath towards Kaikeyi,  was at the verge of realizing her dream of getting due respect ,is shattered again and opens her heart threadbare to lord Raama.

Shlokas have been taken from Vaalmiki Raamaayana, Ayodhyaa Kaanda, Sargah 20.

Shloka 37
Eka Eva hi Vandhyaayaah Shoko Bhavati Maanasah|
Aaprajaasmeeti Santaapo Na Hya-anyah Putra Vidyate||

Roughly it means: A woman without a child (Vandhyaayah) has a grief(Shoka) in mind (Maanasah). I would have had this grief that I don’t have a child but I would not have had any other grief.

Comment: Notice the feeling of bereavement with which Kaushalyaa is going through. Letting her son go, like this, is much more painful than being without a son.

Shloak 38
Na Drishtapoorvam Kalyaanam Sukham Vaa PatiPoureshe|
Aapi Putre Vipashyeyamiti Raamaashtitam Mayaa||

In the glory of my husband (PatiPoureshe) I could not see ( Na Drishta) earlier (poorvam) happiness (Kalyaanam Sukham ). (Hopin that ) However(Aapi), in the glory of Son (Putre) it would be seen( Vipashyeyamiti) by me (Mayaa)

Comment: Kaushalyaa was never happy being “one of the wives” of King Dasharatha. However she had consoled herself that in the era of her son she will get her due. Now the years of patience, craving for respect turns out  be crumbling with 2 boons of Kaikeyi.

Shloka 39

Saa Bahoonyamanogyaani Vaakyaani Hridayachidaam|
Aham Shroshye Sapatneenaamavaraanaam Paraa Satee||

I will hear ( Aham shroshye) many (Bahooni) things which will pierce my heart ( Vaakyaani Hridayachidaam) from my co-wives despite being the eldest wife(Patneenam Varaanaam).

Comment: Kaushalyaa is worried that like before she will keep hearing heart piecing words from co-wives of King Dasharatha (Particularly Kaikeyi)

Shloka 40

Aato Dukhataran Kim nu Pramadaanam Bhavishyati|
Mama shoko Vilaapashcha yaadrishoayamanantaakah||

It seems my grief, bereavement ( Mama shoko Vilaapasha) has not foreseeable end( Yaadhrishoayama-anantaakah).What will be(Kim Bhavishyati) worse grief than this grief (Aatao Dukahataran)

Comment: Look at the importance she has given to this grief. Seems sometimes bearing the co-wife is worse than being childless.

Shloka 41

Twayi Sanihiteapyevamahamaasam Nirakritaa|
Kim Punah Proshite Taata Dhruvam Marannameva hi||

Despite you being near to me (Twayi Sanihite-api) I am being neglected( Ahaam aasam Nirakritaa) (by co-wives). Once you again go to far lands ( Punah Proshite) then my death is a definite ( Dhruvam Marannameva hi) .

Comment: Raama has just returned from his education from Ashram. Kaushalya somehow managed to pass this time. She is fearful of the same fate if Raaama leaves him alone. In Raama kaushalya finds an anchor of her life.


Shloka 42
Atyantam Nigriheetaasmi Bhartunirtyamasammataa|
Pariwaarenna Kaikeyyaah Samaa waapyathawaawaraa||

I have always been neglected (Atayntam Nigriheetasmi) , always dishonored by my husband ( Bhartunirta-asammataa). With Kaikeyi, in our family ( Pariwaarenna Kaikeyyah) I will be as good as her slaves or even worse than that.

Comment: It put Kaikeyi in very poor light. People hate her for her two boons. But as we can see from what Kaushalyaa is speaking, Kaikeyi was a pathetic personality even otherwise too. Perhaps this is the reason we do not name our daughters with the name “ Kaikeyi”


Shloka 43

Yo Hi Maam Sevate Kashchidapi Vaapyanuvartate|
Kaikeyyaah Putramanvikshya Sa Jano Naabhibhashate||

Whosoever (yo hi) provides any service (maam Sevate)  to me or even  tries to follow me ( Api anuvartate), after seeing Kaikeyi’s son ( kaikeyyah Putram- Anviskhya)  they ( sa jano) do not talk(Naabhibhashate) to me.

Comment: This shloka does not give so rosy picture of Bharata. The ideal Bharata is respectful of his mothers and his brother. Either Kaushalyaa has a deep fear of kaikeyi or it is truth or it may be a bit of exaggeration. But, still it remains a worthy point to ponder.

Shloka 44

Nityakrodhatayaa Tasyaah kathaam nu kharavaadi Tat|
Kaikeyyah wadanam drastum Putra Shakshyaami Durgataa||

My son!! Always in anger (Nityakrodhataa), thus peaking harsh words (kharwaadi tat), The kaikeyi--how will I see her(Kaikeyyah Wadanam Drastum)  in mine dire status(Durgataa).

Comment: Kaikeyi while not asking for her boons, otherwise too was in fact very rude and full of anger. Kaushalyaa dreads the thought of seeing her.


This whole episode gives us the vortex of emotions which Kaushalyaa is going through. Layers of emotions of a mother, a wife, a queen, a co-wife, a neglected member of palace, all find place in this episode.  It is painful but still wonderful to read this in Raamaayana. And, much more to find out in Vaaalmiki Raamaayana.

* I may or may not agree with the view of guest writers, but I respect their right to be heard
** You can read Gyan's earlier pieces here:

http://all-about-sanskrit.blogspot.co.uk/2013/04/representations-of-human-beauty.html
http://all-about-sanskrit.blogspot.co.uk/2013/07/representation-of-human-beauty-physique.html
http://all-about-sanskrit.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/in-guest-writer-series-please-welcome.html

Friday, 20 February 2015

Of Caste and Outcaste – Attempt to diagnose the roots of oppression

Please welcome guest writer* Saiswaroopa Iyer. In this passionately written piece, she examines the interstices between caste and power, and ponders on the instrumentality of the varna system in systemic oppression today. You can follow and interact with her on Twitter via her handle @Sai_swaroopa. A Venture analyst by profession, Sai is a dreamer at heart and an aspiring author. She is enthusiastic and passionate about Indian epics, history, literature and classical music. She dreams of a life where reading, writing and singing form the way of life.  


We got rid of the caste system, but not caste-ism” This was an anguished admission of a dear friend of mine whose views generally clash with mine. Yes, in today’s world of hurried and forced labels, one can call him a ‘liberal’ and me, a ‘conservative’. The context of the conversation was based on the electoral dynamics where certain castes end up being the vote banks. I often wondered if I was among the finite minority that cringed every time electoral results are analyzed on TV screens with caste dynamics over riding the real issues. (May be, one could get philosophical and argue about what is real and what is not!)

 My liberal friend and I share a view in common, that we would like to see these lines of caste disappear in our respective ideal worlds. Yes, discrimination is a disease, a disease which requires the medicine of social reformation.  But here I come to the point where I would differ from my friends on the other side of the imaginary line of liberalism. The point is about the diagnosis of the disease. Much of the literature on the social dynamics lays blame on the Hindu fourfold Varna system.  I find the famous line of purusha sukta being quoted with a lot of zeal to prove that discrimination existed right in Vedic texts.

The ones that lay the blame do conveniently forget the openness of the interpretation that the Vedic texts have. My spiritual guru, Bhagawan Sri Sathya Sai Baba had advocated many times that service to the lowest strata of the society is the real ‘pada puja’ made to the universal Lord.

Interpretations and politics apart, I think that the much blamed chaturvarna system died a long while ago. I call it a dead system as the social dynamics of the Varna system had long turned porous and post the dark ages and before the invasions from the middle east, we do have many instances of new dynasties being founded independent of the ‘four-fold’ sanction. The Mauryas, the Guptas, the Shatavahanas, the Kakatiyas and many such empires made a mark in the history defying the much blamed sanction. May be there was no strict sanction and power dynamics redefined the sanction? I would leave it to the historians and period scholars to determine it. The founding of a new empire was often based on pulling down another empire where mostly the King had turned oppressive and unpopular. Empires used to reach the peaks of glory when they balanced the expansion of land with administrative reforms that left the citizens happy. They often reached their peril due to oppressive rule that galvanized a revolution or due to strategic mistakes which gave their rivals an upper hand.

Oppression in such cases in my opinion shifted to power dynamics. Those who wielded power (excluding the heroic kings and reformers who we all remember with reverence) oppressed those who were ideologically opposed to them or presented a threat. That is the reason why I feel blaming the purusha sukta for oppression serves no real purpose and is rather a lazy diagnosis of a serious social problem. The ones doing so probably are not accountable to give a solution so can command the luxury of such lazy diagnosis. But it is important for the ones looking for real solutions to get to the real roots of the problem. When I hear of inhuman practices that prevail among India’s lesser accessible areas, my belief is further strengthened. Though not proud of my knowledge of scriptures, I am yet to come across any such inhuman doctrines which forbid the ‘lower’ class from using the common wells in the village and advocate violent things.  

Oppression is always the language of power maniacs and not of the system writers. As repetitive as I might sound with this sentence, I would want the readers to realize this and more. If one throws the blame of oppression on Hinduism, one has to realize that the defying discrimination also belongs to Hinduism more than the imported idealist theories. I refer to the Bhakti movement and the scores of reforms that were achieved by the likes of Mahatma Basaveshwar, Madhvacharya, the Nayanmars of Tamilnadu and the scores of composers who have denounced all forms of birth based discrimination. My personal favourite is the one in Telugu, “Brahmamokkate” by Sri Tallapaka Annamacharya. Those interested can find the complete lyric and meaning here (http://www.karnatik.com/c1107.shtml). There are more compositions of his decrying discrimination and oppression.

One needs to observe that Bhakti movement scored above the recent movements against caste in one thing – restoring the dignity and in preaching universalism that brought the people of various strata together. Sadly the modern movements though rooted in progressive ideals have done little more than casting the oppressed classes into political toys through reverse discrimination. This is the reason why we see clans and communities aspiring for ‘backward’ tag for reservations and other short term benefits. Sadly, this is the greatest harm that the social engineers of the last century have done to our system. I can only hope that the next wave of reformers would take inspiration from those movements which have advocated the oneness and inherent human merit across the divisions rather than those which have capitalized on mutual hatred and reverse oppression.

* I may or may not agree with the views of the guest writer, but I respect their right to be heard.